You are currently browsing comments. If you would like to return to the full story, you can read the full entry here: “Chinese Medicine Demystified (Part IV): How Acupuncture Works”.
Related posts:
- Chinese Medicine Demystified (Part V): A Closer Look At How Acupuncture Relieves Pain Research continues to shed light on how acupuncture relieves chronic pain and inflammation without significant...
- Chinese Medicine Demystified (Part VI): 5 ways acupuncture can help you where drugs and surgery can’t Five reasons acupuncture beats western medicine as a primary healthcare modality....
- Chinese Medicine Demystified (Part II): Origins of the “Energy Meridian” Myth The idea that Chinese medicine is a psychic, metaphysical medicine is based on gross mistranslations...
- Chinese Medicine Demystified (Part I): A Case of Mistaken Identity Most of what we've been told in the west about how Chinese medicine works isn't...
- Chinese Medicine Demystified (Part III): The “Energy Meridian” Model Debunked Historical evidence and modern research indicate that the Chinese medicine has nothing to do with...
Tags: acupuncture, chinese, four, homeostasis, inflammation, medical, medicine, pain
-
I intend to investigate what you’ve said in more depth later, but for now I have one question, about your second bullet point: Why would micro traumas stimulate healing of old injuries more than the old injuries themselves would? Sorry for my ignorance.
-
I love this series. I have a friend who’s child had severe yeast issues and food intolences when he was young and now they’re gone, she credits acupuncture. Let me comment on the comment above me and please correct me if I’m wrong. Ever since my friend told me about her experience with acupuncture I have been trying to grasp why. I’ve spent a few lunchbreaks digging online and come up with an explanation for mydelf to grap it better: The immune system has several levels it opperates at. If you have an autoimmune diesease your body tends to live with chronic inflammation and the immune system responds to this one way, as you feel the daily aches and pains, let’s call this a low grade response.. When you catch the flu, for example, you immune system has another response, let’s call this a “high grade” response. Say, you discover what was causing your daily inflammation, like gluten. So you pull the gluten out of your diet and you feel better, but not 100 percent. Your “low grade” response still is a bit there. This is because you need the “high grade” response to clean up the damage caused by the gluten. You’ve stopped the additional inflammation by pulling the culprit, but there’s years of damage that needs to be fixed.
The other part to this equation I am trying to learn more about is something called “healing regressions”, which I think works on the same priciple. -
Jesse,
There are several factors which can impair wound and tissue healing:
- Developmental stage: children heal faster than adults because blood flow and fibroblastic ability decrease as we age.
- Poor circulation and oxygenation: physiological disorders such as diabetes and hypertension reduce circulation to peripheral tissues. Smoking, anemia and respiratory disorders decrease oxygenation of tissues. Obesity also delays healing because adipose tissue has a lower concentration of blood vessels.
- Emotional and physiological stress: chronic illness and emotional stress can impair tissue regeneration and wound healing. Poor nutrition, certain medications and environmental toxins can also contribute.
Acupuncture can “jump start” the body’s tissue regeneration and repair mechanisms in spite of these factors. Of course the treatment will be far more effective if these factors are removed.
-
Thank you! I’ve been wary of acupuncture for years because of the mysticism surrounding it. I’m one of those people that needs to know why and how it works, not just that it works. Even with my skepticism I’ve been considering getting it done to relieve the constant tension in my shoulders, now I think I’ll start looking for a practitioner in earnest.
-
Michelle,
I’m so happy to hear that! That was exactly my mission in writing this series – to dispel the common misconceptions about Chinese medicine and increase it’s acceptance amongst patients and doctors. Let me know if I can be of help in finding a practitioner in your area.
-
Thanks for answering my comment! I see. Interesting. Your answer leads me to another question though: What characteristics differentiate damaged tissue from healthy tissue? I mean, what it is that makes damaged tissue “damaged?” Is it an open wound that still hasn’t healed or something?
-
Any kind of injury to the tissue: sprains, tears, pulls, contusions, etc. of muscle, ligament or tendon.
-
Okay, I may have investigated as much as I’m going to. With my limited knowledge, what you say seems plausible. I look forward to the next post. One thing though: could you provide a reference for the statement about acupuncture stimulating release of oxytocin? I’m curious about that.
-
The acupuncture-oxytocin research is still very new. But see here and here for more info. There is abundant evidence that acupuncture stimulates the parasympathetic nervous system regardless of the involvement of oxytocin.
-
Chris, this is one post where we agree EXACTLY. I’d like to add one question to stimulate discussion:
Acupuncture stimulates nerve fibers as proven by experiments such as those conducted by Pomeranz, Stux and Berman. This is physiologic as this stimulation (de qi sensation) is obliterated by naloxone administration. (In fact, I had heard from one patient that this was the straw that broke the skepticism’s back – since naloxone blocked the effect, then it IS physiologic and not just some mystical claptrap). My question is thus: can not the other hemostatic effects of acupuncture be explained by the fact that sensory input passes through the hypothalamus before going to their respective brain areas? This, plus the fact that the hypothalamus contains several nuclei involved in body regulation? -
Chris,
How many treatments do you recommend for your patients before you evaluate the effectiveness for that patient’s injuries?
Thanks. -
Dave,
There are numerous facts that determine the rate of response to treatment, including age, overall state of health, blood flow in the circulatory system, how chronic the injury is, how serious the trauma was, the nutritional status of the patient, whether they are taking medications and at what dosage, etc. I’d say there are no fewer than 40 factors involved in the answer to this question, so it’s not easy to give an estimate without actually seeing you in person. That said, I would estimate that it takes between 3 and 5 treatments to adequately determine future rate of response. Ideally, those treatments should be confined to a 2 or 2.5 week period, i.e. at least 2x/wk treatment.
-
Can you recommend any East Bay practitioners?
Curious, too, if you have any comments on the study of so-called “sham” acupuncture being just as effective as traditional acupuncture. Perhaps it doesn’t even matter where the needles are placed? -
Eliza,
Who I’d recommend depends on what you’re wanting help for. Contact me using this form with that information and I’ll make a referral.
The problem with the studies comparing so-called “sham” acupuncture to “real” acupuncture is that the sham treatment is not inert. In other words, the sham treatment ends up activating the same systemic healing responses that real acupuncture does.
If we understand the neurological basis of acupuncture, then it makes sense that almost any area of the body will be an acupuncture point (because there are nerve endings just about everywhere except for nails and hair). However, it’s been shown that acupoints have a denser concentration of nerve endings and vascular structures, so we might expect those points to work better than non-points. Some studies show this is the case, and others do not.
Speaking from my own experience, point selection does matter. Other practitioners – and even patients – will tell you the same thing. I’ve had patients who responded to my treatments that didn’t respond to other treatments, and vice versa. Granted, we can’t say for sure that point selection was what made the difference. But we can’t say for sure that it wasn’t.
Overall I do think the effects of acupuncture are primarily holistic, meaning that it stimulates the body’s self-healing ability rather than specifically addressing a particular condition. I see this as a tremendous advantage. It means that when someone goes in for elbow pain, not only will that improve, but their depression, IBS and hypertension are also likely to improve.
This is the opposite of what happens with western medicine, where a “specific” treatment for a particular condition (i.e. taking a drug for depression) ends up causing several other new problems (i.e. anxiety, constipation, decreased libido, etc.)
-
I’ve always been open to “alternative” medicine and acupuncture, but I’ve been a little skeptical because of the believes in the energy and meridian concepts. I’ve been thinking that if acupuncture works it must have something to do with either blood flow or nerve stimulation. And this is exactly what you’re saying, so I’m very happy now and can finally think of acupuncture as a complement to nutrition etc. Many thanks for this!
I’m curious. How long does the vascular dilation effect from needle stimulation last? And does it only affect blood flow nearby or does it dilate blood vessels more distant from the stimulated point?
Even if acupuncture for instance can give pain relief I think it’s important to choose the right tool for the right job. Michelle, commenter above, has shoulder pain. I immediately think of posture and if she is sitting much and how. I think that should be looked at first and not use acupuncture right away because that will give some relief. One should search for the root cause first before starting treatment. I have no education in the medicine field, I just read a bunch on the Internet and this is my opinion. Do you share this opinion? But this is not easy, you have to know a great deal about nutrition, emotional stress, posture and muscles, environmental toxins etc to find the real cause.
Having said that, I’d be very interested in hearing what issues you think acupuncture can be the primary treatment method for? Or do you think acupuncture is more useful as a catalysator and helping the body to heal faster after you’ve eliminated the root cause?
Many thanks for the articles. I believe I have one more part to read :) -
Tim,
I’m glad you’re enjoying the series. To answer your questions in turn:
The sources I’ve read suggest the neuroimmune response from acupuncture lasts for two to three days. The effect is systemic. Studies have shown that acupuncture increases blood flow to the internal organs via the vagus nerve.
I agree that it’s always best to find the root cause of the problem. Acupuncture is just one branch of Chinese medicine. It’s kind of like the “physical therapy” of Chinese medicine, in fact. If a patient were to come in with a weight problem, of course the first thing I would do is ask them about their diet. Acupuncture wouldn’t help much in that case if their diet was making them fat. As you’ll see if you peruse my blog, I write mostly about nutrition and lifestyle factors affecting health, so I am in complete agreement with you about their importance.
That said, acupuncture can sometimes help speed the transition. In the case of shoulder pain you mentioned, it’s important to address both the symptom (pain) and the cause (poor posture). We can do both at the same time.
Here’s a list of conditions the World Health Organization has stated can be successfully treated with acupuncture. The list is likely much larger, but it’s a good place to start.
-
What is completely missing from your explanations is how acupuncture works without inserting a needle to stimulate the body’s healing response. Contact needling by blind acupuncturists in Japan obtains equivalent and sometimes better results than acupuncture that punctures the skin with a needle. Poorly designed clinical trials fail to show statistically significant differences between control groups and experimental groups because they stimulate the same points with toothpicks, obtaining a favorable health result even without the insertion of needles. You have a done a nice job of trying to overlay Western on Chinese, but you miss out entirely on elements that are going on outside of your isolated explanations: like with contact needling, or Qi Gong healing. These modalities have the same effects as acupuncture (without a needle to stimulate the Western mechanisms you have described).
-
Crystal,
Penetrating the skin isn’t required to stimulate a PNS response. Contact or toothpick needling would not promote the local tissue response to needling I described, but it could induce the PNS-mediated analgesic response (i.e. activation of the C-delta fibers and subsequent release of endorphins).
There’s still a lot we don’t understand about how it works, and I never claimed that the explanation I offered was exhaustive. However, there’s absolutely no evidence supporting the notion of “energy” flowing through invisible meridians.
I am a long-time practitioner of internal arts such as Qi Gong, Taiji and Ba Gua. There is nothing about these practices that requires the idea of Qi as energy to explain their effectiveness.
-
Hi, thanks for the interesting reading. I am a physiotherapist currently studying western acupuncture and am learning alot about the pathways you have described. I am also trying to pick up on some of the TCM principles which is difficult at times, but its good to know there is a common ground between the two approaches. Is there any danger of treating patients with acupuncture without understanding all of the TCM philosophies? For example, does the direction of twisting the needle actually tonify or sedate the ‘meridian’? Or if I use a point from a western approach, can it have some adverse effect based on TCM?
It explain now why we are still using the same points from thousands of years ago
thanks -
I’ll get myself in trouble with other acupuncturists for saying this, but I don’t believe the various needle techniques (twisting, inserting while breathing in or out, etc.) affect the clinical results much. My acupuncture teacher, Dr. Tan, who lectures all over the world and is a very successful practitioner, doesn’t either – so I’m not alone. I don’t think there’s much danger in performing Western acupuncture without understanding the TCM philosophies. I say that because acupuncture is historically a channel-based therapy, not a “zang fu” therapy as herbal medicine is.
-
Thanks for the reply chris,
Both TCM and the western principles are amazing in their own way, so its nice to hear a mixed approach works. At the moment we are learning about the sympathetic and parasympathetic systems and how needling the ear or scalp points can decrease inflammation through the vagal nerve. Fascinating stuff -
Yes, my understanding is that the concha of the ear is the most accessible site for influencing the vagal nerve. I use ear points in every single treatment because there’s not a person I see that doesn’t need some parasympathetic support.
-
yeah that makes sense, we seem to live in a very pro-sympathetic world. It ties into the stuff you have said about the omega 3-6 imbalance and the chronic inflammation that arises. Personally I am allergic to most fish , although I have just started trying fish oil and this seems ok. I have always had various allergies/asthma & ITP so the lack of omega 3 probably doesnt help
. Do you use pulse diagnosis , and is there any science behind this?
-
Yes, I do use pulse diagnosis but no, there is no scientific explanation that I’m aware of. It’s a mystery, but it works.
-
Nicely done chris,
I too am a senior student of Dr. Tan, and the Master Tung style. I apprecaite your knowledge and explanation. I talk about this all the time. There is NO ENERGY required to do acupuncture. It works off of very biologicaly and scientific reasons. Very easy to understand. As we know, energy is in everything, and at a quantum level we are ALL ENERGY…but this is NOT WHY OR WHY NOT acupuncture works or doesnt work….
thank you….now lets see if we can cant change the entire TCM school system to quit propagating these lies about the invisible meridians and Qi that MISTRANSLATED…it means “vital air”, as in OXYGEN…not energy.
i urge any acupuncturist a MUST MUST MUST MUST read or anybody who want to know the truth of a very scientific and discplined chinese medicine…read
The Dao of Chinese medicine, by Kendall……
Bob doane is a master at explaining this, so Dr. Kendall.
I see over 30 patients by myself each day, i work with doctors–western and Eastern. And do we talk methaphorically about the concepts of chinese medicine? Yes, it helps us understand the disease process. But when it comes to how acupuncture works, there is no use for mistranslated explanations from 1910′s and the 1950′s.
There IS NO MAGIC IN OUR MEDICINE…..
There IS NO MAGIC IN THE NEEDLE….
There is NO MAGIC IN THE HERBS…the magic is the bodies ability to heal once it is given the right healing modality. that is the true magic, the power of the human body, wether we use Eastern medicine, Western medicine, or NO MEDICINE….the body is amazing
thanks again chris, nicely done!!!!
-
Your series is very interesting, and I know there is a desire among many Westerners to understand Chinese Medicine in Western terms, but I do not agree that there is a “moral obligation” on the part of practitioners to be able to trot those mechanisms out on demand. If you can successfully treat patients and have them recover from their illness, is it that important that patients know the physiological mechanisms that do the job? Do patients in the West know how the statin drugs they are taking do what they do, and why? Do they even know why the aspirin they take helps alleviate their headache? On the other side of the coin, do successful treatments based on Meridian Theory mean that the acupuncturist just got lucky, while poking around in the dark? I think there is much more work to be done in reconciling the thought processes and perceptions of East and West.
-
I see where you’re coming from, but I can’t agree with your analogies. I do believe patients should be informed about how statins work (and don’t work, actually) so they can decide whether they need to take them at all, or can use other less invasive, less harmful methods. The same for aspirin. I also believe – and the research clearly supports this – that when a patient 1) has a positive attitude about their treatment, and 2) believes that it will work, the treatment will be more effective. Explaining how acupuncture works in language they can understand is a step in that direction for most, although there’s certainly a minority of patients (and practitioners) that prefers a more mystical, magical explanation.
Stay connected!
Subscribe to podcast in iTunes
27 comments
Comments feed for this article